Problem with Blogger’s Embedded Comment Form! A Regression Bug?

If you have noticed recently, for past few weeks I am using Blogger’s Embedded Comment form in place of the pop-up version. This is done via combination of Blogger Draft's new experimental feature and a simple hack to embed the form beneath every post. This new embedded comment form had been working nicely till now and as I checked an hour back, to my horror I noticed that the "Comment as:" drop down is empty and does not show any options to choose from. At first look I thought it was due to some accidental change in my own template during recent code refactoring. But when I checked around the blogosphere I came to notice that other blogs using this feature are also showing this problem. Moreover even the Blogger in Draft itself shows the same problem!

Though it comes as a relief to know that this bug is not something in my blog alone, still it is a terrifying scenario for any blogger like me who likes to see readers leaving comment on their blog post. Hope the Blogger team has already spotted this minor looking yet critical (from a functionality stand point) bug and must be working on it to deliver a quick fix.
Here is a screenshot of the bug below:

I have tried it in different browsers like IE 6,7, Mozilla Firefox 3 and Google Chrome. And unfortunately the bug shows up irrespective of your browser and/or screen resolution. Moreover, in IE I am getting this script error that is pointing to a possible problem at Blogger's side:
I am waiting for a quick fix from the Blogger team. In case they fail to deliver a quick enough fix, I would probably revert back to the earlier less user-friendly but at least functional comment form for now. In the mean time if you wish to leave me a comment, feel free to use my Contact Me form.

Blogger has not yet fixed this bug. Looks like Blogger is having problem in replacing the Blog ID and the Post ID while retrieving data from it's server via this ( URL. Usually Blogger replaces the "xyz" with the publisher's Blog ID and the "abc" with the Post ID. In fact for some blogs, it is actually replacing the data correctly and importing the javascript file ( successfully. But for others (like mine) it is failing to do so resulting in the empty "Comment as:" drop down box. [NOTE: Thanks to 'Kimberly Salem' for pointing this to me.]

However, as a temporary workaround I have reverted back to the earlier pop-up version of Comment form so that you (the readers) will be able to leave comments. I am tracking this Blogger bug and I am already with contact with the Blogger team. Hopefully I would be among the firsts who would be intimated in case there is a fix. It would be my pleasure to update you all when ever there is a fix. Stay tuned for more updates...

Looks like this issue has been mysteriously fixed now. I have reverted back to embedded comment form in my blog and it is working. I have seen it working in other blogs too. Though Blogger team is yet to announce this fix officially, it has started working again. If you had removed embedded comment form in your blog then revert back to it now and see if it is working!

Happy Testing…
Share on Google Plus

About Debasis Pradhan

Debasis has over a decade worth of exclusive experience in the field of Software Quality Assurance, Software Development and Testing. He writes here to share some of his interesting experiences with fellow testers.


  1. I am so glad someone is on this problem. I am having the same issue with one of my blogs, but not the other, so combed through my template code with no luck at fixing the problem. I hope they get it fixed ASAP!

  2. Oh my god, I really hope the problem will be solved soon,I am feeling I am losing many comments on my blog.

  3. Hi, FYI I have just seen that the embedded comment form on "Blogger in Draft" is working now. It looks they have corrected something on their blog but still no reply to my question there.

    Many blogs still doesn't work with the inline comments.

    Have a nice day!

  4. This has been a huge pain in the butt! How about testing it before you roll it out and lock up the comments on tons of blogs? I expect more from Blogger, this isn't some fly-by-night operation. And I've been asking for help on the issue @ the Blogger Help Group, and no blogger staff has responded in spite of repeated requests throughout the past week. Disappointing.

  5. Hi Debasis, thanks for tracking this bug. It was really troubling bloggers like me and now it is a great relief to see it is working again. Thank you.

  6. ehmmm,.i see now,..
    Is this blog go on Busby Seo Test

  7. i am still facing this problem..

  8. It's not working for me yet

  9. hey this is just great i have been looking for this info for a while now ! thank very much !

  10. i have problems with my comment section too!!nobody is able to comment in my blog!I've tried changin the templates too,but it doesn't seem to work...please help!!I'm freakin out!

  11. :)

    First time i've heard of regression bugs on blogger

  12. I still have this problem on my blog:

    It crashes the window

  13. Thanks for sharing your post and it was superb .I would like to hear more from you in future too.

  14. Thank you for sharing with useful information. It was nice to read the review. Try to use outsource software development company thats allow you to get custom development software for your business.


NOTE: Comments posted on Software Testing Tricks are moderated and will be approved only if they are on-topic. Please avoid comments with spammy URLs. Having trouble leaving comments? Contact Me!